Állatorvosi szakértői tevékenység a laboratóriumi vizsgálatok tükrében = Investigating cases of animal cruelty – the perspective of the laboratory pathologist

Szalay, Dóra and Fézer, Brigitta and Törőcsik, Réka and Thuma, Ákos (2023) Állatorvosi szakértői tevékenység a laboratóriumi vizsgálatok tükrében = Investigating cases of animal cruelty – the perspective of the laboratory pathologist. MAGYAR ÁLLATORVOSOK LAPJA, 145 (9). pp. 545-554. ISSN 0025-004X

Text 545_554_Szalay_allatvedelem.pdf - Published Version Restricted to Repository staff only Download (9MB) | Request a copy

Abstract

Magyarországon az állatkínzás büntetőjog által szankcionált cselekmény. Ahhoz, hogy az állatkínzásos büntetőügyekben megfelelő bírói ítéletek szülessenek, alapos, releváns és a szakkérdés megválaszolásához szükséges minden részletre kiterjedő szakértői ténymegállapítások szükségesek. Jelen közleményben a szerzők tanulságokat és tapasztalatokat igyekeznek átadni az elmúlt 4 év (2019–2022) hatósági eljárás keretében végzett laboratóriumi diagnosztikai anyagaiból, ill. felhívni a figyelmet az ez irányú patológiai vizsgálatok buktatóira, és ezzel mintegy támpontokat adni egy esetleges állatorvosi szakértői munka elvégzéséhez. | Background: In Hungary, animal cruelty is a felony sanctioned by the Penal Code. Experts can greatly assist juries in issuing appropriate judicial verdicts. Expert findings that cover the necessary details and answer all technical questions aid juries to determine the facts in an animal cruelty case. Hence, it is extremely important to continuously improve the quality of the examination routines of the veterinary expert. This includes the efficiency of forensic pathology, which is required to provide more appropriate expert statements. Objectives: This study aims to share experiences from laboratory diagnostic cases carried out at the request of the local authority in the framework of the official procedure. The authors intend to draw attention to possible mistakes in routine pathological examinations, and thus provide a better perspective for veterinary expert work. Materials and methods: All the examinations are taken from official cases, each performed due to suspicion of animal cruelty. The forensics carried out by the Veterinary Diagnostic Directorate regional Pathology Departments from the beginning of 2019 to the end of 2022. Results and Discussion: During the 4 years period 165 official requests were received. On a pathological basis, the most frequently diagnosed offender behavior was abuse, followed by neglect, and lastly poisoning. Considering the animal abuse crime, out of all wound types, half of the cases were bullet trauma. During the crime scene investigation, sampling has a decisive influence on the effectiveness of the subsequent pathological work. Therefore, special attention must be paid to sending the sample in the correct way. Furthermore, veterinarians participating in expert work must know the documentation to be recorded both during on-site inspection and pathology. Prosecutors require the appropriate knowledge and understanding of the evidence in question to present and challenge expert evidence. It is also worth mentioning that experts are getting increasingly into the focus of social interest due to social sensitivity, which is further amplified by the fiction of media products.

Actions (login required)

Edit Item