Does Political Equality Require Equal Power? A Pluralist Account

Mráz, Attila Gergely (2023) Does Political Equality Require Equal Power? A Pluralist Account. ETHICAL THEORY AND MORAL PRACTICE, 2023. ISSN 1386-2820

Preview

Text Mraz_2023_forthcoming_Does_Political_Equality_Require_Equal_Power_A_Pluralist_Account.pdf - Published Version Available under License Creative Commons Attribution. Download (836kB) | Preview

Abstract

In this paper, I criticize two views on how political equality is related to equally distributed political power, and I offer a novel, pluralist account of political equality to address their shortcomings—in particular, concerning their implications for affirmative action in the political domain, political representation, and the situation of permanent minorities. The Equal Power View holds that political equality requires equally distributed political power. It considers affirmative action—e.g., racial or gender electoral quotas—, representation, and more-than-equal power to permanent minorities pro tanto objectionable. The Equal Status View, in contrast, holds that political equality concerns equal relations and status, and it is only contingently related to equally distributed power. I argue that while the Equal Status View is right that equal power can be insufficient for—or even objectionable from the viewpoint of—political equality, it is wrong to conclude that equal power has no independent significance in an account of political equality. My pluralist account shows that political equality entails not only status-based requirements but also independent egalitarian requirements to distribute political power equally. This account provides a finer-grained understanding of affirmative action in the political domain. It justifies affirmative action but holds that it should only be used to realize equal political status until thorough-going social reform allows us to maintain both equal political status and equally distributed political power at the same time. Similarly, representation should be amended with power-balancing institutions, and permanent minorities should enjoy equal status with minimal compromise to power equality.

Actions (login required)

Edit Item