György Alajos Szerdahely and Heinrich Philipp Conrad Henke: details of a cultural history debate from the 1780s

Balogh, Piroska (2024) György Alajos Szerdahely and Heinrich Philipp Conrad Henke: details of a cultural history debate from the 1780s. CAMOENAE HUNGARICAE, 9 (1). pp. 30-45. ISSN 1786-5484

Preview

Text balogh.pdf - Published Version Download (217kB) | Preview

Abstract

This study examines an intellectual debate from the 1780s that is primarily represented by three Latin texts published in German journals and two corresponding Latin epistolary exchanges. The discourse originated with an anonymous letter in the Annales Literarii Helmstadienses in 1782 that criticized the Jesuits for allegedly stifling scientific and cultural advancement in Hungary. György Alajos Szerdahely, an ex-Jesuit professor at the University of Pest, responded with an apologia defending the Jesuits’ contributions to Hungarian education and culture. Three years later, Elek Horányi, a Piarist scholar, rebutted Szerdahely’s arguments, emphasizing the Piarists’ greater role in the dissemination of modern scientific philosophy in Hungary. The study contextualizes the debate within the editorial practices of Annales Literarii Helmstadienses, edited by Heinrich Philipp Conrad Henke, a theologian with strong ties to the intellectual circles of Göttingen. Letters between Henke, Szerdahely, and another key figure, János Krizosztom Hannulik, reveal the cultural and personal dynamics underpinning the publications. The analysis highlights the role Latin played as a medium of transnational scholarly exchange and explores how historiography has ignored Szerdahely’s oeuvre despite its intellectual impact. The findings underscore the cultural and methodological tensions between Jesuit and Piarist scholars, reflecting broader shifts in educational and scientific paradigms during the late eighteenth century. This research contributes to a deeper understanding of Latin scholarly networks and the critical reception of Jesuit contributions in early modern Hungarian intellectual history.

Actions (login required)

Edit Item