Identity, Integration, and Loyalty in Estonia: A Relational Comparative Analysis of Immigrant Integration

Polynin, Ivan (2026) Identity, Integration, and Loyalty in Estonia: A Relational Comparative Analysis of Immigrant Integration. INSTITUTIONES ADMINISTRATIONIS - JOURNAL OF ADMINISTRATIVE SCIENCES, 6 (1). pp. 87-104. ISSN 2786-1929

Preview

Text IAJAS_article_216_vol6_no1.pdf - Published Version Available under License Creative Commons Attribution. Download (586kB) | Preview

Abstract

This article presents a relational comparative analysis of Estonian integration, building directly on Marju Lauristin’s cluster analysis and national defense index in the Estonian Integration Monitoring 2023. Drawing on relational integration theory and John W. Berry’s acculturation framework, it maps Lauristin’s clusters onto Berry’s four strategies and traces ethnic differences in trust, belonging, support for NATO, and military aid to Ukraine. The analysis identifies important limitations in Lauristin’s symmetric design: even when integration is framed as a two-sided process, asymmetrical power relations persist, and acculturation strategies continue to collapse into assimilation, separation, or marginalization. The post-2022 security context amplified these pre-existing cleavages. Vetik’s national unity-versus-equal-rights imperatives remain central, yet the majority has claimed the moral high ground by framing strong support for Ukraine as a loyalty test. And the relational lens shows that this securitization of integration has proved counterproductive, widening trust gaps across the whole society.

Actions (login required)

Edit Item