Does the sovereign exist? Robert Musil’s political theology

Balázs, Zoltán (2022) Does the sovereign exist? Robert Musil’s political theology. INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY AND THEOLOGY (ROUTLEDGE), 83 (1-3). pp. 163-179. ISSN 2169-2327

Text Musil-Anselm.pdf - Draft Version Restricted to Repository staff only Download (120kB) | Request a copy

Abstract

The paper discusses a possible political theological interpretation of arguments developed in Robert Musil’s The Man Without Qualities. What emerges is that Musil (or his characters) pose a fundamental challenge to the possibility of any real analogy between God and the political sovereign, as suggested by Carl Schmitt. At stake is Austria as a yet-to-be-born modern sovereign. However, the novel shows why attempts to conceive it in an image of God all fail. After surveying four such attempts, the main focus will be the discussion of Anselm of Canterbury’s existential argument in this secular context. At Diotima’s inspiration it is General von Bordwehr, a largely neglected figure, who makes the most serious attempt to argue for the political sovereign as the greatest conceivable thing. The argument is that greatness entails containing every idea and its opposite, and this yields the concept of order. But order means the frozen end of everything. Hence, instead of a living God, we end up with a political sovereign marked by death.

Actions (login required)

Edit Item