The First Amendmentand Global Online Speech

Caprice, L. Roberts (2026) The First Amendmentand Global Online Speech. PUBLIC GOVERNANCE ADMINISTRATION AND FINANCES LAW REVIEW, 11 (1). pp. 17-34. ISSN 2498-6275

Preview

Text PGAFLR2026_1_02_8712_Roberts.pdf - Published Version Available under License Creative Commons Attribution. Download (665kB) | Preview

Abstract

This article explores the tensions of free speech and censorship where social media platforms reign supreme in the U.S., but experience the Brussels effect in Europe and beyond. The catalyst for this inquiry is U.S. congressional efforts to investigate alleged EU censorship of American speech. This article examines competing interests and comparative approaches. In the absence of comprehensive regulation in the U.S., companies engaging in multi-country activity operate under the shadow of European regulation. Does compliance threaten to chill American speech? Is balancing the interest of deterring disinformation possible where freedom of thought is paramount to American ideals? Institutional self-regulation creates a competitive marketplace with some American social media giants engaging in heavy-handed content regulation while others claim to let anything go short of targeted harassment. The aim of this article is to honour American free speech and press principles while appreciating genuine threats that may threaten other core American values such as democracy. Balancing benefits and harms remains preferable given American constitutional and policy priorities. To what extent can the – self-enforced and judicial – remedies reflect this balancing approach like equitable relief rather than the blunt hands of banishment and censorship?

Actions (login required)

Edit Item