REAL

The Foreclosure of Contestability

Papp, Victor (2026) The Foreclosure of Contestability. DUNAKAVICS, 14 (10). pp. 33-68. ISSN 2064-5007

[img]
Preview
Text
25242-ArticleText-99081-1-10-20261014.pdf - Published Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial Share Alike.

Download (444kB) | Preview

Abstract

Misinformation and polarising forms of platform power are commonly treated as failures within an otherwise available public sphere. This first part of a three-part inquiry proposes foreclosure as a diagnostic concept for a different condition. Democratic capacities persist in protected institutions and deliberately constructed forums, yet the prevailing architecture of the public sphere fails to reproduce them reliably or connect them to institutions capable of collective decision. An architecture forecloses a condition when its ordinary operation no longer reproduces that condition, when the arrangements securing it remain local or provisional or depend on resources that do not govern the architecture, and when no reliable mechanism carries local instances to the scale at which democratic practice binds. The third clause identifies non-composability and separates the concept from communicative degradation, colonisation, blocked circulation between periphery and centre, and second-order democratic disorder. I attribute the causal mechanism to an optimisation regime characterised by behavioural feedback, institutionally selected objectives, individuated informational environments, and rapid revision, and state five conditions for revising the diagnosis or its causal account. A genealogy of public-sphere theories and comparison with rival causal accounts then narrow the claim. Optimisation functions as an infrastructural mechanism whose effects vary with media systems and with the institutions that own and regulate them.

Item Type: Article
Uncontrolled Keywords: Deliberatív demokrácia, digitális nyilvános szféra, algoritmikus kuráció, foreclosure, nem-komponálhatóság, optimalizáció, platformhatalom, kollektív akaratképzés
Subjects: H Social Sciences / társadalomtudományok > H Social Sciences (General) / társadalomtudomány általában
SWORD Depositor: MTMT SWORD
Depositing User: MTMT SWORD
Date Deposited: 08 Nov 2026 18:52
Last Modified: 08 Nov 2026 18:52
URI: https://real.mtak.hu/id/eprint/249799

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item